Reflections on the European Order
The recent negotiations in Abu Dhabi shed light on Moscow's attempt at a rethinking of Europe’s security architecture
Corina Cristea, 20.11.2026, 13:24
While failing to yield any decisive progress toward resolving the most brutal conflict in Europe since World War II, the recent negotiations in Abu Dhabi involving Russia, Ukraine and the US highlighted Moscow’s stance, which sees a resolution to the conflict in Ukraine as part of a broader rethinking of Europe’s security architecture.
This idea has been firmly opposed by Ukraine’s leader Volodymyr Zelenskyy, who emphasised that the EU and NATO are the only genuine security for Europe, and warned that the Kremlin’s attempt to alter the continent’s security architecture is dangerous and could entail new wars.
With these statements, Moscow skilfully constructs a justification for refusing to halt hostilities, says George Scutaru, the founding president and executive director of the New Strategy Center. According to him, these issues will stay on the agenda of the stakeholders in the coming period:
George Scutaru: “We must be aware that this war will go on, and not just for weeks or months; it will, in all likelihood, extend well into next year. As long as no pressure is put on Russia to prevent its economy from benefiting from rising oil prices and to ensure it no longer has enough resources to sustain its war machine, Putin has no incentive to end this conflict. He believes he can ultimately secure Ukraine’s defeat and force the Europeans to reduce their aid, thereby achieving victory on the Ukrainian front. We must understand that the stakes of the war in Ukraine extend beyond that country alone. Russia speaks of a ‘security architecture’ in Europe; we should remember the demands Russia publicly presented to the US and NATO on December 17, 2021, a demand clearly articulated by the Russians: the withdrawal of all military infrastructure from the states that joined the North Atlantic Alliance after 1997.”
Just months before the Kremlin launched its so-called “military operation” in Ukraine, Russia had presented the US and NATO with two draft agreements concerning security guarantees. Demands included halting NATO expansion, particularly toward Ukraine and other states in the former Soviet space; withdrawing NATO infrastructure and military presence from the countries that joined the Alliance after 1997; limiting the deployment of troops and weaponry to Eastern Europe; prohibiting certain Western military activities in Ukraine and other states in Russia’s neighborhood; and imposing restrictions on the placement of nuclear weapons and missile systems.
All of this stems from Russia’s view that the current European security order is unbalanced as a result of NATO’s eastward expansion following the Cold War, which saw Moscow lose its influence over states that had once been part of its traditional sphere of control.
So the idea put forward by Moscow is not new; accepting these conditions would have been, then as now, a major shift in the European security balance. It would have essentially given Russia the ability to exert influence over NATO’s military decisions and the foreign policy choices of independent states.
As for the European Union’s position? “In 2021, Russia’s demands were a pretext for war. In 2026, they are pretext to keep the war going,” said the EU’s foreign policy chief at the end of a European Union Council meeting. Kaja Kallas added that in turn, “Europe has clear demands towards Moscow. Just to recall some of them: Ukraine’s sovereignty, independence, territorial integrity, and the right to choose its own alliances must be respected. There can be no legal recognition of the occupied Ukrainian territories. Russia must be held accountable for war crimes and pay for the destruction they have caused. Children deported from Ukraine must be returned home. Russian sabotage and cyber-attacks across Europe must end.”
A ceasefire followed by a peace agreement must be a priority, Kallas emphasised. “Only then we can discuss anything else. Ministers were very clear today. We do not need a new security architecture. We need to restore the one we have. Russia has broken all the treaties that unpin it.”
Meanwhile, Putin continues to reject any ceasefire. Moscow is attempting to exploit weaknesses in Ukraine’s air defences and is putting pressure on Ukrainian cities because its gains on the front line are virtually non-existent, says George Scutaru:
George Scutaru: “Over the past two months, Russia has lost rather than gain territory, as the Ukrainians have managed to carry out attacks, although limited ones, that have allowed them to reclaim some territory and settlements in Donetsk and Zaporizhzhia. This has come at a high cost, with the Russians suffering approximately 30,000 casualties per month. Russia is trying to use the US as leverage to exert pressure on the Ukrainians, and we must recall various decisions taken by the Trump administration over the last month: the agreement on diesel, which effectively brings Russia back into the global trade of non-sanctioned fuels; the curbing of the Graham Act that would have placed additional pressure on third countries purchasing energy from Russia; and now, the issue of a security architecture has emerged, with the Russians already bringing up the concept of a ‘Eurasian security architecture.’ This is a topic through which Russia seeks to complicate negotiations and make them difficult to manage in a very short timeframe; in reality, it serves as a pretext to avoid agreeing to a truce.”
All in all, we can say that the war in Ukraine is not merely a military confrontation for territory control. Behind peace negotiations and diplomatic statements, a much broader dispute is taking shape, concerning who sets the security rules in Europe and where the limits of Moscow’s influence over the former Soviet space lie. (AMP)